Four psychiatrists in the UK specialising in autistic spectrum disorders give their professional conclusions on whether Sherlock has autism or Asperger’s Syndrome:
- A consultant psychiatrist specialising in diagnosing autistic spectrum disorders in adults.
- A consultant child/adolescent psychiatrist
- A neuropsychiatrist currently researching Asperger’s Syndrome
- A consultant psychiatrist with a special interest in learning disabilities
There has been much debate on this topic but most of it is conducted without any expert knowledge. This meta aims to rectify the balance and make people aware of the real life negative consequences of suggesting that Sherlock has Asperger’s.
A Disclaimer Before we Start
I am a medical student, I know quite a lot of psychiatrists and I managed to interview some of them for this article. These psychiatrists have kindly given up their time to talk about this so please respect their professional knowledge and what they have to say.
I hesitated a lot about publishing this because I’ve had so much hate mail over my previous meta on the subject (Sherlock and His Asperger’s).
Why do we need this dissection? Because real people are being affected by the suggestion that Sherlock has Asperger’s or Autism. The writers decided to throw in the term “Asperger’s” in THoB, and while they may have intended it as a joke, many people including at least two real patients took it very seriously, which caused a great deal of distress to them and their families.
This meta is about making people aware that suggesting Sherlock has a certain disorder is both misleading and harmful.
the fact that peter capaldi has ALREADY ARGUED with moffat about scripts is extremely promising
Let us pray
do u ever lie on ur side and a small tear leaks out and ur just like whoa wtf body I know I’m sad but not that sad